Home > Financial Articles > Financial Planning > How to Know When It's Time to Change Your Financial Advisor

How to Know When It's Time to Change Your Financial Advisor

article

A financial advisor plays an important role in shaping your financial future, guiding you through major life decisions, such as retirement planning, investment strategies, and wealth management. Having a suitable advisor can mean the difference between achieving your financial goals and falling short. According to a study by Vanguard, working with a qualified financial advisor can add up to 3% in net returns annually through behavioral coaching, portfolio rebalancing, and tax efficiency.

However, not all advisor-client relationships stand the test of time. Circumstances change, and so do financial goals. If your advisor’s strategies no longer align with your needs or their communication leaves you feeling unsupported, it might be time to consider a change. Switching advisors isn’t just about finding someone better; it is about ensuring your financial well-being is in the hands of someone who truly understands your goals and values.

This article will help you identify when it is time to change financial advisors, the costs and tax implications of switching, and the steps to ensure a smooth transition.

Below are some of the signs it’s time to change your financial advisor:

1. Lack of communication

Clear and consistent communication is necessary for an advisor-client relationship to be successful. If your advisor falls short in this area, it can leave you feeling unsupported and uninformed about your financial progress.

  • Infrequent or delayed responses: If you frequently have to chase your advisor for updates or answers to your questions, it’s a sign they’re not prioritizing your needs. A good advisor should respond promptly to inquiries, especially during volatile market conditions or significant life events.
  • No regular updates or meetings: Advisors should proactively schedule regular check-ins to review your portfolio, discuss your goals, and provide updates on financial strategies. If your advisor isn’t initiating these discussions, they might not be fully engaged in managing your financial well-being.

2. Charge high fees without providing value

Paying fees for financial advice is expected, but those fees should correspond to the value and results you’re receiving. If you suspect you’re overpaying or not getting your money’s worth, research the fees charged by other advisors offering similar services. If your advisor’s fees are significantly higher without any added benefits, it’s time to evaluate whether you require your advisor’s services.

Clarity is also an important factor here. If your advisor’s fee structure is unclear or you’re surprised by unexpected charges, it can erode trust. A reliable advisor will clearly explain their fees and ensure you understand what you’re paying for.

3. Misaligned financial goals

A financial advisor should tailor their strategies to your specific goals, preferences, and circumstances. If their approach consistently diverges from what you want, it’s a major red flag. Advisors who promote investment products or strategies without considering your unique needs might be more focused on their preferences or commissions than your success.

Additionally, investments that don’t align with your risk tolerance or long-term objectives can jeopardize your financial security. An advisor who disregards these factors is not acting in your best interests.

4. Underperformance

While no advisor can guarantee perfect investment returns, a pattern of poor performance or failure to meet reasonable benchmarks is a cause for concern. If your portfolio repeatedly underperforms compared to market indices or peer benchmarks, it’s worth questioning whether your advisor’s strategies are effective.

Advisors should be open to adjusting strategies when market conditions or your goals change. If your advisor dismisses concerns or fails to explain underperformance, it indicates a lack of accountability.

5. Trust issues

Trust is the foundation of any advisor-client relationship. Once it’s broken, it’s difficult to repair. If you suspect your advisor of unethical practices, such as recommending products for their commissions rather than your benefit, it’s a clear signal to move on.

Advisors who are vague about their strategies, fees, or performance metrics may be hiding something. Transparency is essential for building confidence in their advice.

6. Conflict of interest

Your financial advisor should always act in your best interests. Conflicts of interest can compromise their ability to provide unbiased advice. Here are some signs of conflict of interest:

  • Prioritizing commissions: Advisors who consistently push products tied to higher commissions may not have your best interests at heart. A fiduciary advisor, on the other hand, is legally obligated to act in your best interests.
  • Recommendations that don’t align with your needs: If your advisor’s advice seems more beneficial for them than you, it may be a sign of a deeper conflict of interest.

What are the various costs of changing financial advisors?

Switching financial advisors can be a smart move for your financial health, but it’s important to understand the costs associated with the process. While the potential benefits of finding a suitable advisor often outweigh the expenses, knowing what to expect can help you make a more informed decision. Here are the key costs you should consider when changing financial advisors:

1. Termination fees

Financial firms often impose termination fees when you transfer accounts, which can vary depending on the firm and the type of account.

  • Typical fees charged: Termination fees generally range from $50 to $150 per account. These fees can add up quickly for investors having multiple accounts (e.g., brokerage, IRA, and joint accounts).
  • Hidden contract fees: Some firms embed additional charges in their terms of service, such as penalties for early termination or minimum holding periods for certain investment products. It’s essential to review your existing advisor’s contract carefully to identify any hidden fees before making the switch.

2. Transfer costs

Transferring your investments from one advisor to another can incur brokerage and administrative services costs.

  • Brokerage charges: If your advisor suggests selling existing assets and repurchasing them, you may incur transaction fees, especially if the investments are held in taxable accounts. This can also trigger capital gains taxes.
  • Administrative fees: Some firms charge administrative fees for processing account transfers, ranging from $25 to $75 per account. These costs can vary based on the complexity of the account transition.

3. Opportunity costs

Switching financial advisors can temporarily disrupt your financial planning, potentially resulting in opportunity costs. Transitioning accounts often takes time, and during this period, your portfolio may not be actively managed, leading to missed opportunities to adjust strategies based on market conditions or life events. Additionally, the transfer process carries the risk of administrative errors or delays, which could leave some of your assets uninvested, ultimately reducing potential returns.

4. New advisor fees

When selecting a new financial advisor, you’ll need to consider their fee structure, which may differ from your current advisor’s.

 
ad_article

Need a financial advisor? Compare vetted advisors matched to your specific requirements.

Choosing the right financial advisor is daunting, especially when there are thousands of financial advisors near you. We make it easy by matching you to vetted advisors that meet your unique needs. Matched advisors are all registered with FINRA/SEC. Click to compare vetted advisors now.

Tax implications of switching financial advisors

Switching financial advisors may have tax implications, particularly when assets are sold or transferred. Being aware of these potential tax consequences can help you make informed decisions and avoid unexpected liabilities.

1. Capital gains taxes

When you sell appreciated assets during the transition to a new advisor, you may incur capital gains taxes.

  • Taxes on appreciated assets: Capital gains taxes apply to profits made from selling investments, such as stocks or mutual funds, outside of tax-advantaged accounts. These taxes can vary based on your income and whether the assets were held short-term (taxed as ordinary income) or long-term (taxed at preferential rates).
  • Tax-loss harvesting: To offset gains, consider selling underperforming assets at a loss. This strategy, known as tax-loss harvesting, can reduce your taxable income and potentially save you money during the transition.

2. Retirement account transitions

Switching advisors for tax-advantaged accounts, such as IRAs and 401(k)s, requires careful handling to avoid triggering unnecessary taxes or penalties.

  • Rollover or conversion taxes: Rolling over a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, for instance, may result in immediate taxation on the amount converted. Evaluate whether the long-term benefits outweigh the upfront costs.
  • Rules for transfers: Direct transfers between custodians (trustee-to-trustee transfers) can be done without incurring taxes or penalties. Ensure that these transfers are correctly executed to maintain the tax-deferred status of your accounts.

Reducing the financial impact of switching advisors

Below are some ways to reduce the financial impact of switching advisors:

  • Negotiate fees: Some firms may waive termination or transfer fees if you ask. Additionally, your new advisor may be willing to cover some of these costs as an incentive to earn your business.
  • Time the transition: If possible, transition your account at the start of a new billing period or before annual fees are charged to avoid double-paying fees for overlapping services.
  • Retain existing investments: If your current investments align with your financial goals, consider keeping them intact to avoid unnecessary brokerage fees or capital gains taxes.
  • Review fee structures: Before committing to a new advisor, compare fee structures to ensure you’re receiving better value for money. Ask for a transparent breakdown of all costs.
  • Consult a tax professional: Work with a tax expert to minimize capital gains taxes through strategies like tax-loss harvesting or deferring asset sales.

Steps to Transition to a New Financial Advisor

Changing financial advisors involves several important steps to ensure a smooth transition. By approaching the process methodically, you can minimize disruptions and set yourself up for success with a new advisor.

Step 1: Notify your current advisor

Maintaining professionalism during the transition ensures a smoother process.

  • Professional communication: Inform your current advisor of your decision to terminate the relationship. Keep the conversation polite and focused on your needs.
  • Complete necessary paperwork: Work with your current advisor to finalize any required documentation, such as transfer forms or account closure requests.

Step 2: Transfer your accounts

Efficiently transferring your accounts can minimize disruptions to your financial plan.

  • Collaborate with your new advisor: Your new advisor will guide you through the account transfer process, ensuring compliance with regulations and minimizing errors.
  • Minimize delays: Confirm all required documentation is submitted and track the progress of your transfers to avoid unnecessary delays.

Step 3: Monitor the transition

Once the transition is complete, closely monitor your accounts and evaluate the performance of your new advisor.

  • Verify account balances: Ensure that all assets have been accurately transferred and there are no discrepancies in account balances.
  • Track performance: Regularly review your portfolio’s performance and maintain open communication with your new advisor to address any concerns.

What to look for in a new financial advisor

The ideal advisor should possess the skills, integrity, and dedication to guide you through complex financial decisions while aligning with your unique needs. Here are the key factors to consider when selecting a new advisor:

1. Credentials and expertise

A qualified financial advisor brings specialized knowledge and credibility to their role. Look for certifications such as Certified Financial Planner (CFP®), Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA), or Certified Public Accountant (CPA). These credentials indicate that the advisor has undergone rigorous training, adheres to ethical standards, and has expertise in areas like investment management, tax planning, and retirement strategies. Additionally, if you have specific needs, such as estate planning or managing a business, prioritize advisors with relevant specialized experience.

2. Fiduciary duty

A fiduciary advisor is legally obligated to act in your best interests, providing an important safeguard for your financial well-being. Fiduciaries prioritize your needs over their own, avoiding conflicts of interest that could arise with non-fiduciary advisors who may recommend products for commissions. To ensure this commitment, ask potential advisors if they operate as fiduciaries and request written confirmation.

3. Fee structure transparency

Understanding an advisor’s fee structure is vital to avoiding surprises and ensuring value for money. Common fee structures include:

  • Flat fees: A fixed amount charged annually or per service, ideal for predictable costs.
  • Hourly rates: Fees based on the time spent on specific tasks, suitable for occasional advice.
  • Percentage of assets under management (AUM): A model where advisors charge 0.5% to 1.5% of your portfolio annually. While this aligns their incentives with your portfolio's growth, it can become costly as your assets grow.

Always request a detailed breakdown of fees and check for hidden costs.

4. Alignment with your financial goals

A good financial advisor tailors their strategies to reflect your unique needs, preferences, and objectives. They should take the time to understand your financial goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon, creating a personalized plan that evolves with your circumstances. Avoid advisors who push pre-packaged solutions without fully considering your specific situation.

5. Communication and trust

Look for advisors who provide regular updates about your portfolio’s performance and market conditions, explain complex financial concepts in simple terms, and empower you to make informed decisions. Early signs of trustworthiness include transparency, responsiveness, and a genuine interest in your financial success.

To conclude

Switching financial advisors is a significant decision, but it can be transformative for your financial future. By recognizing the signs it’s time to switch, understanding the costs and tax implications, and following a structured transition process, you can make the change with confidence.

Prioritize your financial goals and seek an advisor who aligns with your needs, values, and objectives. A suitable advisor will help you navigate complex financial decisions, and provide peace of mind and a clear path to achieving your dreams.

Use the free advisor match tool to get matched with seasoned financial advisors who can help attain financial goals based on your specific needs, circumstances, and risk tolerance. Answer some simple questions about your financial needs and get matched with 2 to 3 advisors who can best fulfill your financial requirements.

You may also be interested in

Get matched with the best financial advisors near you to guide you towards your financial goals

The blog articles on this website are provided for general educational and informational purposes only, and no content included is intended to be used as financial or legal advice.
A professional financial advisor should be consulted prior to making any investment decisions. Each person's financial situation is unique, and your advisor would be able to provide you with the financial information and advice related to your financial situation.